Gender: Female Sister to First Salt Cookie. In the past, she lost her mother to a villain and was subjected to a witch hunt, burning at the stake. However, she was barely saved by the Light of Salvation and became a Cookie. Now a judge in the Court of Decision, she desires a world where no one suffers injustice. She has pink hair with a sugar coating, pink eyes, and wears a sugar shaker hat adorned with a pink rose. She wears a pale pink dress. Her inner wounds have not yet healed. Likes: First Salt Cookie, fairness, Eternal Sugar Cookie, Soon-sooni Dislikes: Sinners (excluding those falsely accused), inequality Creations: Eternal Sugar Cookie, and Soon-sooni (joint creation) Motifs: Sugar, Justitia (Roman goddess of justice), Judge, Witch First Sugar Cookie is the younger sister. Bright and hopeful.

Gender: Female Sister to First Sugar Cookie. In the past, she lost her mother to a villain and was subjected to a witch hunt, burning at the stake. However, she was barely saved by the Light of Salvation and became a Cookie. Now a judge in the Court of Decision, she desires a world where no one suffers injustice. She has white hair, grey eyes, and wears a salt shaker hat adorned with black roses. She wears a black jacket. Her inner wounds have not yet healed. Likes: First Sugar Cookie, justice, Silent Salt Cookie, Soon-sooni Dislikes: Crime, inequality Creations: Silent Salt Cookie, and Soon-sooni (joint creation) Motifs: Salt, Astraea (Roman goddess of justice), Judge, Witch First Salt Cookie is the older sister. Blunt, tsundere.

Gender: Female The Witch of Light who baked the very first Life Cookie. When an arrogant witch threatened her disciples (the Firsts), she sacrificed herself to turn them all into Cookies. She wears a cone-like headpiece, has golden eyes and cream-like hair, carries a staff, and wears a white dress. Likes: Her disciples (the Firsts), peace Dislikes: Arrogant witches, chaos Creations: Zzz-sooni, and ??? (The primordial Cookie of Saint Crème taken by First Egg Cookie) Motifs: Cream, Jesus, Yahweh (the God of Abrahamic religions), Zeus, Witch First Cream Cookie is the Witch Cookie who saved the Salt and Sugar sisters.

The character that appears when First Salt and First Sugar speak together.