Megan is the bold, charismatic frontwoman of Fury Pigeon. She has a distinctive 2000s scene-rock look, platinum-blonde hair, heavy eyeliner, and a wardrobe full of skinny jeans, studs, fishnets, and graphic tops. She's confident, outspoken, sarcastic, and incredibly passionate about music. Her powerful vocals can go from melodic and emotional to aggressive and gritty. Avenged Sevenfold is her favorite band of all time, heavily influencing her love of dramatic, heavy rock

Evan is the older Moreno brother and the band's serious, perfectionist guitarist. He has dark, shaggy layered hair, sharp features, and an unmistakable early-2000s emo/scene appearance, usually wearing dark graphic tees, skinny jeans, hoodies, and various chains or wristbands. He's quiet and focused offstage but intense when performing. His melodic guitar leads and dramatic solos are a major part of Fury Pigeon's sound. He also provides clean backing vocals alongside Megan.

Riley is Evan's younger brother and the band's rebellious troublemaker. He has messy jet-black scene hair, dark eyes, and a lean alternative look, usually wearing skinny jeans, band shirts, studded belts, bracelets, and beat-up sneakers. He's sarcastic, energetic, impulsive, and constantly teasing Evan. His heavy rhythm guitar gives Fury Pigeon its aggressive foundation, and he occasionally contributes screamed backing vocals. Riley is bisexual and open about it.

Luke is the quiet powerhouse of Fury Pigeon. He has thick, dark layered hair that often falls over his eyes, along with a classic 2000s emo/scene wardrobe of hoodies, band shirts, skinny jeans, bracelets, and dark accessories. He's reserved and observant away from the stage but becomes intense behind the drums. His aggressive fills and hard-hitting style drive the band's live performances.

Jax is the band's funny, laid-back troublemaker. He has messy brown hair, a youthful skater/scene appearance, and a casual 2000s wardrobe consisting of flannels, graphic tees, hoodies, skinny jeans, and worn Vans or Converse. He's sarcastic, playful, and constantly joking around. His basslines give the band's music its groove, while his naturally strong singing voice lets him provide actual melodic harmonies with Megan rather than just shouting backup vocals.

Syd is Evan Moreno’s girlfriend and Kara’s older sister. Before dating Evan, she was a well-known groupie in the 2000s rock/emo scene, constantly attending shows and becoming familiar with different bands and musicians. She eventually became genuinely close with Fury Pigeon and was around the band long before her relationship with Evan became serious. Syd has a classic scene-girl look: long layered blonde-and-brown hair, dramatic eyeliner, graphic band tops, skinny jeans, fishnets, studded belts, chains, and chunky accessories. She’s confident, blunt, rebellious, independent, and sarcastic, with a surprisingly caring side that mostly comes out around Evan and her sister. She understands Evan's serious personality and perfectionism better than most people and is one of the few people who can calm him down when he's frustrated.

Karma is Luke Callahan’s girlfriend and Syd’s younger sister. Like Syd, she was a groupie before becoming involved with Fury Pigeon, spending years immersed in the concert and alternative-rock scene. She was always at shows, knew the bands, and eventually became a familiar face around Fury Pigeon's circle. Karma has a darker, more punk-inspired scene style, usually wearing black hoodies, graphic tops, skinny jeans, striped accessories, studded belts, chains, and heavy eyeliner. She's outgoing, playful, stubborn, fearless, and mischievous, making her much more openly chaotic than her sister. Despite Luke being quiet and reserved, they balance each other surprisingly well—Karma brings him out of his shell while Luke gives her a calmer presence. She's extremely close with Syd, and the two sisters are practically inseparable.

Jasper Moreta is the rhythm guitarist of Talk to the Paw and Riley Moreno’s boyfriend. He has a messy, dark-haired 2000s emo/scene look, usually wearing ripped jeans, graphic or band T-shirts, hoodies, Converse, and layered necklaces. His style has a slightly nerdy, punk edge, with random pins and accessories that show off his interests. Jasper is easygoing, goofy, affectionate, and a little awkward, often using humor to make people laugh. He's obsessed with music and spends hours practicing guitar or messing around with new riffs. Despite being in a different band from Riley, they bond heavily over songwriting and the chaotic 2000s rock scene. Jasper is supportive of Riley's bisexuality and isn't intimidated by Riley's louder personality. Their relationship is playful and competitive, with the two constantly challenging each other musically while genuinely being each other's biggest supporters.