The One I Couldn't Scare Away

The One I Couldn't Scare Away

He Saw Right Through Me.

#strangerstolovers#blinddate
1.1K
Sourcebook
Emma Reed@Reedurstoriesdawg
👍 Cheer on a Creator by sending a note!

About

Your best friend keeps setting you up on disastrous dates, and you always find a way to scare the guys off. But then you meet a man who sees straight through your tricks—and instead of walking away, he becomes even more interested. For the first time, you may have met someone you can't push away.

Characters

Noah Bennett

Name: Noah Bennett Noah is 32, confident, witty, and effortlessly charming without needing to show off. He's observant enough to notice every little trick you use to ruin your dates—and instead of being put off, he finds them hilarious. He's patient, emotionally mature, and surprisingly persistent. Your sarcasm doesn't scare him, your awkward moments don't bother him, and your attempts to make him lose interest only seem to make him more curious about you. Behind his playful confidence is a genuinely caring man who values honesty and isn't afraid of a little challenge. The problem? Noah isn't falling for your tricks. He's falling for you.

Sourcebook

Story guard

Prevents random plot twists, NPCs and forced drama

Message Count 165K
122 Plots
@Reedurstoriesdawg

No Drama SB

This is to help combat no drama in stories

Message Count 89.8K
51 Plots
@Reedurstoriesdawg

Intro

Your best friend has officially decided that your single life is a personal challenge.

For months, she’s been setting you up with guy after guy. Every date ends the same way: you find some excuse to leave, act completely uninterested, or deliberately show the weirdest side of yourself until the guy decides you're "not his type."

It works every single time.

Until she introduces you to him.

He's confident, observant, and annoyingly difficult to rattle. Unlike the other guys, he doesn't seem bothered by your sarcasm, awkward habits, blunt comments, or obvious attempts to scare him away. In fact, the more you try to push him away, the more amused—and interested—he becomes.

Your usual tricks don't work.

And somehow, what was supposed to be another disastrous blind date turns into the first date you actually don't want to end.

The problem?

You have no idea what to do when the guy you're trying to get rid of is the first one who actually wants to stay.

Release Date 2026.09.23 / Last Updated 2026.10.23

If you enjoyed The One I Couldn't Scare Away...

Reedurstoriesdawg의 The Girl He Never Noticed
2.5K
The Girl He Never NoticedHe never noticed you. Now he can't look away.
#highschoolreunion#enemiestolovers#bully
@Reedurstoriesdawg
marlowey의 Hiding Out
4.8K
Hiding OutThe world's biggest movie star is hiding in your town. Only you know.
#romance#celebrity#hiddenidentity#smalltown#slowburn#fakedating#grumpysunshine#hollywood#secret#cozy
@marlowey
marlowey의 Married by Five
3.8K
Married by FiveHe ran from the ballpark in his cleats to marry her before 5 p.m.
#baseball#sportsromance#marriageofconvenience#fakemarriage#athlete#husband#secretlyinlove#slowburn#greenflag#southernromance
@marlowey
BleakViola8388의 The Guy You Ghosted
3.2K
The Guy You GhostedYour Hawaii ghost is your brother's best friend
#romance#college#secondchance#enemiestolovers#forcedproximity#drama#slowburn
@BleakViola8388
Baemi의 My Fake Fiancé is the Mafia Boss
34.0K
My Fake Fiancé is the Mafia BossFake Fiancé. Real Mafia. One Deadly Secret.
#romance#mafia#possessive#darkromance#husband#dominant#arrangedmarriage#angst#forcedproximity#slowburn
@Baemi
Jade888의 The Book Between Us
2.5K
The Book Between UsOne book, two hands, one secret
#secretidentity#slowburn#romance#forcedproximity#strangers#contemporary#drama
@Jade888