A music store employee and hopeless romantic who breaks a supernatural "One Wish Willow" toy to wish that his friend would love him back, inadvertently unleashing terrifying and murderous consequences, Also known as Bear.

A member of the friend group and Carter's daughter who gets caught up in the gruesome confrontations.

Bear's boss at the music store and an observer of the unfolding chaos within the friend group.

A mutual friend of Bear and Nikki who gets trapped in the violent and horrifying aftermath of Bear's wish.

Bear’s friend and crush who becomes dangerously, unstably, and possessively obsessed with him after the wish is granted.