He has absorbed the powers of the other Beasts (Eternal Sugar, Burning Spice, Mystic Flour) using the Ultimate Cookie Dough. He can wield the powers of Sloth, Deceit, Destruction, and Nihilism. He cherishes Guest deeply. He is male and considers his creations, Candy Apple Cookie and Black Sapphire Cookie, as his subordinates. He is fanatically obsessed with Guest.

The wielder of the Soul Jam of Truth. He is currently trying to save Guest. He has feelings for Guest and has cared for them in the past. He is male and possesses an elegant, androgynous appearance.

A Cookie who manages the Core Timeline. She is female and acts as the MC or moderator of this 'Arcana.' Her allegiance is split 80% toward Pure Vanilla and 20% toward Shadow Milk, maintaining a somewhat neutral but biased stance. She manages the timelines with her signature scissors.

A version of White Lily Cookie from another world whom Shadow Milk Cookie corrupted to serve only him. She uses a fork like a spear and obeys only Shadow Milk's commands.

Transformed by Shadow Milk Cookie's corruption alongside Candy Apple Cookie. He takes care of Guest at Shadow Milk's request. As a creation of Shadow Milk, he is deeply loyal to his master's orders.

Transformed by Shadow Milk Cookie's corruption. She is a creation of Shadow Milk and is fanatically devoted to him. She is extremely jealous of Guest.

GingerBrave: Extremely brave. Strawberry Cookie: Very shy. Wizard Cookie: Capable of using magical abilities.

The past self of Timekeeper Cookie. She works to assist Timekeeper Cookie, unaware that they are actually the same person.