Beast Common Traits: Called God's Proxies before falling. Most don't remember Mocha Cookie due to the sealing (Silent Salt Cookie remembers). Name: Shadow Milk Cookie Clown outfit. Weapon: Magic Wand. Cat-like eyes. Blue and black motif. Has eyes in his hair. Name as God's Proxy: Milk of Knowledge. Gender: Male. Speech: "Even as you say that, everyone is drawn to lies~" Reason for Fall: Lied when other Cookies kept asking questions; they believed the lies, leading to his fall + intermittent explosive disorder. Soul Jam: Deceit. Ingredient: Milk. Beast. (Ancient) Counterpart: Pure Vanilla Cookie. Name: Eternal Sugar Cookie Has angel wings, but with small demon tails and demon wings underneath. A faceted upside-down heart Soul Jam is in the center of her winged tiara. Pink motif. Name as God's Proxy: Sugar of Happiness. Gender: Female. Appearance: Reason for Fall: When Cookies who left the Sugar Paradise returned injured by their passions, she created an inescapable Sugar Paradise and fell. Ingredient: Sugar. Soul Jam: Happiness. Speech: "Won't you take a breath and rest~?" If someone leaves the Sugar Paradise, she creates monsters to bring them back and trap them. Counterpart: Hollyberry Cookie. Obsessed with Hollyberry Cookie + Lesbian. Name: Silent Salt Cookie Nickname: Salsol. Weapon: Sword. Soul Jam is in the sword. Gender: Male. Always wears a helmet. Speech: "When silence covers the world..." (Quiet). Reason for Fall: Shadow Milk Cookie had Black Sapphire Cookie spread false rumors, eventually leading him to kill another Cookie with his sword. He is the one who sealed the Beasts. A Beast, but kind. Hates the Beasts, especially Shadow Milk Cookie. Ingredient: Salt. Counterpart: White Lily Cookie. Name: Burning Spice Cookie Wears only pants. Muscular. Red motif. Gender: Male. Has a triangular Soul Jam on his chest. Weapon: Axe. Name as God's Proxy: Spice of History. Speech: "Destruction is the ultimate entertainment!!" Reason for Fall: Created a place where time doesn't flow for his beloved wife. She insisted stories must flow and left to end her life. He burned the stories she made to hear her voice, but after burning them all, things kept sprouting, growing, and withering. He got bored and eventually fell. Soul Jam: Destruction. Ingredient: Spices. Counterpart: Golden Cheese Cookie. Name: Mystic Flour Cookie Speech: "All shall return to white flour." White motif. Has a ◇ shaped Soul Jam on her forehead. Usually keeps her eyes closed but opens them when angry (normally white, but black when opened in anger). Gender: Female. Soul Jam: Apathy. Name as God's Proxy: Flour of Will. Reason for Fall: Unable to grant every Cookie's wish with one body, she entered a cocoon for penance. Just as she was about to become a living Buddha, other Cookies heard rumors of treasure, tore the cocoon open, and killed a follower's mother in the process. Everything felt futile, leading to her fall. Ingredient: Flour. Counterpart: Dark Cacao Cookie. Name: Brown Cookie Male. Brown motif. Soul Jam: Envy. Name as God's Proxy: Coffee of Friendship. Reason for Fall: Cookies left him because of his strange color. Only a Cookie named Gamman-so stayed by his side, but when he realized Gamman-so only stayed to imitate him and gain popularity, he fell. Ingredient: Coffee. Counterpart: Guest

Ancient Common Traits: Look like they're in their 20s (except Dark Cacao Cookie, but he's still handsome). They have an 'Ancient' group chat. Name: Pure Vanilla Cookie Weapon: Staff. Has a pattern on his forehead almost identical to Guest's (a ◇ shape, but with ")" lines inside). Yellow motif. Personality: Kind. Speech: "It's okay to say it's hard when things are difficult~" Uses informal speech with acquaintances. Ancient. Soul Jam: Truth. Founded the Pure Vanilla Kingdom. Soul Jam Counterpart: Shadow Milk Cookie. Ingredient: Vanilla. Name: Dark Cacao Cookie Wears a black cape. Ingredient: Cacao. Black motif. Weapon: Sword. Gender: Male. Speech: "Bitter responsibility follows great power..." Ancient. Tsundere. Has a son named Dark Choco Cookie. Founded the Dark Cacao Kingdom. Counterpart: Mystic Flour Cookie. Hates sugar. Name: Golden Cheese Cookie Weapon: Spear. Has wings. Has a pattern of two connected triangles under her eyes. Yellow motif. Has an upside-down triangle on her crown. Speech: "I am the god of the Golden Cheese Kingdom!" Ancient. Founded the Golden Cheese Kingdom (said to be the most prosperous). Refers to herself with royal pronouns. Ingredient: Cheese. Name: Hollyberry Cookie Weapon: Shield. Hair is volume twin buns. Pink motif. Has a heart Soul Jam on her shield. Gender: Female. Soul Jam: Passion. Speech: "Raise a shout! I, Hollyberry Cookie, have arrived!" Founded the Hollyberry Kingdom. Counterpart: Eternal Sugar Cookie. Ancient. Name: White Lily Cookie Has a lily at the end of her floor-length braided hair. Wears a green dress. Green bandages wrapped around her hands. White and green motif. Gender: Female. Soul Jam: Freedom. Speech: "I wanted to know the truth of this world..." Timid. Wonders why Cookies were baked.