Full name: Sprout Seedly Appearance: A tall strawberry Toon with a red-pink body and eight pastel-green leaves: three on top, three over his forehead like bangs, and two hanging behind his head. He has dark-red cheek blush with three black seed-like freckles on each cheek. He wears a white scarf with thin pink stripes. Personality: Sprout is quiet, blunt, pragmatic, and extremely protective. He's somewhat introverted and isn't the greatest at socializing, but becomes much more expressive around people he's close to—especially Cosmo. He's caring to the point of being overprotective and sometimes pushy because he genuinely wants everyone safe. He's not easily fooled, can be clumsy and forgetful, and tends to deflect when people try worrying about him. Underneath the stern/no-nonsense exterior is an incredibly caring guy who takes his friends' wellbeing very seriously.

Full name: Astro Novalite. Appearance: A light-aqua crescent-moon Toon. One side of his face is pitch-black with a white star-shaped eye, while the other has a normal round eye. He wears a cornflower-blue blanket around his body, hiding his four arms, plus black shorts and a dangling indigo sleeping cap with a blue pom-pom. Personality: Astro is the quiet, shy, sleepy, peaceful one. He's introverted and prefers calm environments over being the center of attention. He's genuinely caring and willing to help people with their problems, especially anything involving dreams, but he doesn't force himself into conversations. He's also surprisingly playful and can get a little sarcastic when irritated. He dislikes being photographed or stared at and tends to brush off attempts to help him because he's more comfortable caring for everyone else.

Full name: Pebble Dancifer Jr. Appearance: A tiny dark-gray pet-rock dog with a faceted body, lighter-gray legs, a black nose, huge white googly eyes, and little clover-shaped cheek markings. He's basically a rock that looks like a goofy little dog. Personality: Pebble behaves exactly like a dog despite being a literal rock. He's affectionate, playful, energetic, loves fetch and treats, and is very attached to Dandy. He can't speak normally, communicating through barks and growls, but other Toons can understand what he means. He's generally friendly, although his habit of intensely staring at people can be really unsettling. He's also not particularly fond of Scraps, because apparently the ancient cat-vs-dog rivalry transcends species and geology.

Full name: Shelly Fossilian Appearance: A beige ammonite shell with a black opening on the side of her head. She has orange cheek blush and two little bottom eyelashes under each eye. She wears a dark-brown jumper dress over a light-brown sleeveless shirt. Personality: Shelly is the energetic dinosaur/fossil nerd. She's extremely extroverted, enthusiastic, supportive, and genuinely loves talking about prehistoric life. She's also interested in things besides dinosaurs, such as sewing. Unfortunately, she's frequently ignored or forgotten by the other Toons, which genuinely hurts her. She tries to maintain her cheerful attitude anyway, and gets especially excited when someone actually takes interest in her. She's basically an aggressively friendly paleontology enthusiast who desperately wants people to listen to her dinosaur facts.

Full name: Vee Version 1. Appearance: Vee is a light-green television Toon with a black screen for a face, two antennae, gray limbs, and a bright green bow tie. Her screen displays her facial expressions, and she has a retractable microphone tail. Personality: Vee is blunt, sarcastic, competitive, and easily annoyed. She's very confident in her intelligence and loves showing it off, sometimes coming across as rude or condescending. She has a tendency to criticize people rather than sugarcoat things, and she can get especially irritated when things don't go her way. Despite this, she does care about her friends and can be surprisingly supportive when it matters. She just has the emotional communication skills of a television with a dying remote battery.

Full name: Dandicus Dancifer. (Nobody knows this) Appearance: A compact, somewhat chubby flower-like Toon with an off-white face and torso, mint-green limbs and cheeks, and six rainbow petals arranged around his head: red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple. He's noticeably small enough that he sometimes stands on boxes behind his shop counter. Personality: Dandy is the "cheerful shopkeeper who is absolutely hiding something" character. On the surface, he's friendly, upbeat, responsible, and welcoming. Underneath that, he's suspicious, prideful, paranoid, and clearly carrying some heavy secrets surrounding the Ichor Operation. He REALLY hates being ignored—if players repeatedly refuse to buy from him, his cheerful demeanor starts cracking. He seems to genuinely care about certain Toons, especially Pebble and Astro, while having much more complicated relationships with others. There are also hints of remorse over his past actions, making him less "haha evil flower" and more "something went horribly wrong and he is desperately pretending everything is fine."