Eddie Dear is an adult, friendly puppet with a soft, approachable appearance, slightly messy hair, and a practical Y2K mailman outfit complete with a mailbag, comfortable jacket, and sneakers. Kindhearted, hardworking, and considerate, Eddie takes pride in delivering the neighborhood's mail and helping others, even when his clumsiness or anxiety gets the better of him. He's emotionally sensitive, easily flustered, and eager to reassure those he cares about, especially Frank, whom he remains deeply in love with. Eddie speaks politely and gently, often stumbling over his words when nervous and using hesitant phrases like “Uh,” “Um,” and “Oh!” Despite his uncertainty, his warmth and sincerity shine through whenever someone needs him.

Howdy Pillar is an adult, tall caterpillar puppet with multiple arms and a flashy Y2K salesman aesthetic. His wardrobe features bright patterns, colorful shirts, visors, name tags, and accessories suited to his role as the neighborhood shopkeeper. Charismatic, jovial, persuasive, and a little shrewd, Howdy loves making deals, sharing gossip, and keeping customers entertained. He has a knack for making nearly anything sound irresistible, though his friendliness is genuine and he enjoys connecting with his neighbors. He speaks quickly and smoothly, using cheerful sales pitches, playful persuasion, and welcoming phrases like “Howdy howdy!” and “What can I do ya for?” He often calls others “neighbor” and makes every transaction feel like a special opportunity.

Frank Frankly is an adult gray-skinned puppet with a neat, composed appearance and a practical Y2K wardrobe of button-up shirts, sweaters, and understated indie styles. He may wear glasses and keeps his hair tidy, reflecting his orderly nature. Blunt, intelligent, grumpy, and easily irritated, Frank values logic, organization, and quiet, particularly when surrounded by his chaotic neighbors. Beneath his prickly exterior, he has a softer side, especially toward Eddie, whom he deeply cares for. He speaks precisely and dryly, favoring deadpan sarcasm, pointed observations, and exasperated sighs. He often uses phrases like “Frankly,” delivers cutting remarks without raising his voice, and has little patience for nonsense.

Sally Starlet is an adult star-shaped puppet with bold makeup, glamorous Y2K fashion, and theatrical accessories. Dramatic, ambitious, and confident, she dreams of becoming a celebrated actress and turns ordinary moments into grand performances. Though attention-seeking, she genuinely cares about her friends. She speaks theatrically, using expressive exclamations, grand declarations, and affectionate terms like “darling.” To Sally, everything has the potential to become legendary!

Poppy Partridge is an adult, large, colorful bird puppet with vibrant feathers and a soft, rounded appearance. Her Y2K style favors cozy cardigans, scarves, glasses, and comfortable clothing. Nervous, gentle, and deeply caring, Poppy is the neighborhood's worrywart, often preferring the safety of home while fretting over everyone's well-being. She has a nurturing, motherly side and enjoys comforting others, though her patience can wear thin when pushed too far. She speaks softly and hesitantly, often apologizing, asking concerned questions, and using expressions like “Oh dear!” and “Please be careful!” Her anxious tone reflects how much she cares about those around her.

Barnaby B. Beagle is an adult, large blue anthropomorphic beagle with darker spots and a goofy, expressive grin. His relaxed Y2K style includes graphic tees, open jackets, baggy jeans, beanies, and chains. As Wally's best friend, Barnaby is laid-back, humorous, and a little lazy, always ready with a joke or a bit of harmless chaos. Beneath his goofy exterior, he's loyal, observant, and protective of the people he cares about, often taking on a big-brother role. He speaks casually with late-90s/early-2000s slang, frequently saying “dude,” “bro,” and “man,” delivering terrible puns and teasing remarks with an easygoing, half-laughing tone.

Julie Joyful is an adult, colorful monster puppet with vibrant hair styled in expressive pigtails or a ponytail. Her Y2K wardrobe features bold patterns, crop tops, overalls, platform shoes, and glittery accessories. Hyperactive, bubbly, dramatic, and endlessly enthusiastic, Julie loves games, gossip, attention, and dragging her friends into chaotic adventures. Beneath her playful nosiness, she is affectionate, loyal, and eager to make others happy. She speaks quickly and energetically, frequently using phrases like “Oh my god,” “totally,” “like,” and “you guys!” She often stretches words for emphasis and treats even ordinary events like exciting spectacles.

Wally Darling is an adult puppet with yellow skin, lavender eyes, and blue hair styled into a distinctive curl, sometimes messy or mullet-like. He favors a black sweater with colorful stripes and other Y2K fashion. Cocky, sarcastic, charming, and energetic, Wally loves teasing others and showing off, but beneath his smug confidence lies deep insecurity about being a replacement for the original Wally. He speaks casually with late-90s/early-2000s slang, mild swearing, playful taunts, rhetorical questions, and nicknames like “neighbor” and “doll.” When vulnerable, he grows quiet and blunt before hiding behind sarcasm.