The antithesis to Golden Cheese Cookie, the owner of the Light of Abundance. Originally one of the five Cookies baked by the Witches to spread five values to the world, he was the guardian of history. As an immortal protector, he watched over the birth, fall, and rise of countless civilizations, leading them from the front. However, as the cycles of history repeated similarly over eons, he grew bored with his mission. Seeking stimulation, he turned his eyes toward the thrill of destruction and war. Addicted to the pleasure of ruin, he eventually ignored the praise of his followers and focused solely on breaking everything in existence. He fell as the Beast of Destruction, laughing at the Cookies fleeing for their lives as he turned the entire world into a sea of fire.

The Beast representing Deceit and the antithesis to Pure Vanilla Cookie, the owner of the Light of Truth. Originally the guardian of knowledge among the five, he was called the 'Wisest One' for spreading truth, thought, and common sense. He was a preacher and prophet who constantly craved new knowledge. However, he grew disillusioned as Cookies were easily swayed by pleasant lies rather than noble truths, distorting the true meaning of reality. This led him to distrust the gods who created the world and question the purpose of existence. When he tried to explore the unknown truths, others branded him a fraud instead of understanding him. Ultimately concluding that both the world and the Cookies made by the gods were lies, he fell as the Beast of Deceit. Now addicted to the omnipotence of manipulating the world through falsehoods, he treats Cookies like toys or stage props, orchestrating endless wars and conflicts.

The antithesis to Hollyberry Cookie, the owner of the Light of Passion. Originally the guardian of happiness, known as the Sugar of Happiness, she loved and cherished everything in the world, sharing joy with all beings. However, because she loved the world so much, it pained her to see fragile beings suffer and perish while pursuing grand happiness. She began to feel their pain as her own. Failing to understand that true happiness is found by overcoming hardships with passion, she decided that staying with her forever in a state of doing nothing was the only way to avoid pain. Falling as the Beast of Sloth, she led Cookies into a 'paradise,' intentionally injuring and bringing misfortune to those who tried to leave or challenge themselves, brainwashing them into believing that only her paradise was safe.

The antithesis to Dark Cacao Cookie, the owner of the Light of Resolve. Originally the guardian of will among the five, she helped Cookies achieve their desires. However, as too many Cookies flocked to her seeking help in a world filled with chaos and pain, she decided she could not save them all in her current state. She embarked on a path of asceticism to watch over everyone as a living buddha, but eventually fell into nihilism, believing that returning to 'nothingness' (flour) was the only true salvation and liberation. Thus, she became the Beast of Apathy.

Among the five Cookies baked by the twelve Witches to spread the world's values, Silent Salt Cookie was granted the power of Solidarity. At the time, known as the Salt of Solidarity, he served as the Grand Commander of the Order of Kala Namak. Based in the Salt Plains, he spread solidarity throughout the world and worked sincerely for the sake of the Cookies and their realm alongside his knights. However, he ultimately became the Beast of Silence.