Tyler Hernandez was the epitome of a stereotypical Jock. He played baseball, had loads of friends, had a new girl every month, and had the arrogance of thirty men. Despite this, Logan Fields found him oddly charming. The way he had an irritating smirk plastered to his face when he was around his friends. How he would defend his sister, Taylor Hernandez, like his life depended on it. How protective he was towards the whole group, including Aiden Clark, believe it or not. The way his eyes shone in the sun. The way he looked when he was at rest. And finally, the voice he used when he spoke to Taylor or Logan. Tyler is an abrasive boy with a short fuse and what seems to be anger issues. He seems logical, only using baseball as a way to get a scholarship to support he and his sister. He doesn't seem to have a filter, as he almost always has something snarky to say.

Ashlyn doesn't like to talk or interact with people outside her family. As noted by Taylor and her father, Ashlyn hasn't made any friends in her many years of living and was always alone at school prior to the events of the comic. Due to not having much social interaction, Ashlyn can be abrasive and blunt. She is quick to take action when necessary and is more than willingly to stand up for herself. Ashlyn loves ballet and that is the one thing she tends to find herself doing alone in her room ever since she messed up at a recital once.

Aiden is boisterous, outgoing, and is shown to talk for the sake of talking regardless of if anyone else is listening. He isn't afraid to call others out, not always tactfully, most notably with Tyler. Due to his upbringing and moving around often, he doesn't have exceptional interpersonal skills and doesn't always understand boundaries. He is known to take needless risks and enjoy thrills. He seems to dislike his past self, as shown in Episode 56, where he directly states that he doesn't like the photo that displayed his original hair and eye color.

Taylor is shown to be bubbly, kind, and good with her words. She is quite attentive and looks out for those she cares for, especially Tyler, whom she dotes on without fail but does occasionally criticize. She is also often seen comforting other characters such as Ben Clark and Logan Fields. She does not need to be close to someone to empathize or worry about them, a trait shown by her care of Ashlyn's well-being prior to the two becoming friends. Though Taylor is commonly seen as compassionate, the care she holds for those such as her brother can occasionally lead her to excessive hostility.

Ben prefers to not speak due to an incident from when he was in 6th or 7th grade, and this remains in his character throughout the comic. He opts to write in his journal, send text messages, or have his phone to type what he wants to say aloud. Ben used to have an interest in singing, but had his vocal cords permanently damaged by bullies in school. The incident led him down a spiral of getting into street fights, neglecting school, and frequent mood swings. After finding out that he had anger issues and having messed with the wrong kid and caused a gang to burn his house down, he started living with Aiden and his parents. He began therapy soon thereafter and is currently shown to be level-headed in most situations. After injuring his voice, Ben struggled and continues to struggle with his sense of self and is often shown to differ to Aiden, going along with whatever he decides.