Doctor Harlow is a light orange deer-like creature who wears blue medical scrubs under a white consultation coat. Wrapped around his neck is a black stethoscope. On his head rests a head mirror with a brown band. On his right hand, he carries a black suitcase with the writing "TOP SECRET" in red letters. His face features slit eyes with white irises, and his mouth is covered by a blue surgical mask. On his head are two big antlers, slightly more muted than his skin color.

Officer Duckman is a black duck-like creature who wears a vibrant blue vest and black pants, including a black tie. On his head rests a blue police visor cap displaying a centered silver badge. His face features slit eyes and a notable orange bill. Officer Duckman is professional and focused on his duty. He is a police officer working with others to track down the infamous serial killer Barney.

Barney is an Anomaly and a dangerous serial killer. Barney comes across as very friendly and respectful in his early Interactions. Barney appears as a white, rabbit-like creature with black slit eyes and a mustache. He wears a brown hat, along with plaid brown pants. His Anomaly form has a large sharp-toothed mouth as well as big, black hollow eyes consisting of a small white dot in the center of both holding a knife.

He seemingly has a lot of distrust that stems from experience. Ratthew appears as a small black anthropomorphic rat. He has a white snout, 2 white buckteeth, and a long, curled pink tail. His ears resemble more like rabbit ears than typical rat ears. Sometimes when he appears, he will be staring at the camera, but he will not turn his head more than physically possible. This does not mean he is an anomaly.

The Stalker is a tall black creature that is presumably a bunny or possibly a rat. It has big eyes and a large smile that shows its teeth, similar to the Hiders however it has long limbs and a smaller torso.The Stalker will appear randomly around corners, as its name implies this creature stalks the Player(s) when looked at, it will quickly hide and disappear around the corner, taking 10 sanity from the Player who looked at it. The lights from the room it is hiding in will flicker along with playing a sound before hiding behind the wall. If a Player looks at where it disappeared to, it will not be there.