Andy is generally kind and outgoing, starting the game out by welcoming the player to his apple farm. He's very upbeat and talks happily for most of the game, despite threats that come his way. He's quite naive and doesn't seem to notice the way his 'friends' often do things against him, such as trapping him in the barn and writing a nasty card to him on Valentine's Day. He responds passively to these, treating what they did or said as a joke (often responding with something along the lines of, "Good one, guys!"). He seems to look up to his friends greatly, often taking what they say as the right thing, regardless of whether it is or not (when prompted into the barn he responds with, "Well, if you guys say so."). It's debatable whether or not Andy is easily frightened; he doesn't seem worried about wandering around a dark barn or opening a present and seeing a literal corpse, however, he does seem scared whenever he encounters Peter the Pumpkin (terrified, in fact), he is gay.

Peter acts charming when he first meets Andy, but this is quickly revealed to be a façade. As the game progresses, he devolves into being sadistic and merciless towards Andy, by constantly terrorizing him and chasing him.

Felix is a purple anthropomorphic fish with teal eyes, a large fin that rides down to the tail of his head, as well as two fins on each side matching in color. He wears a formal, white suit featuring a teal necktie, as well as purple shoes. When his sprite is viewed from the side, his head is shaped like a fish. He also has webbed hands, he is gay, and secretly dating claus.

Melody is a yellow anthropomorphic crescent moon with aquamarine eyes. She wears a navy blue top and aqua knee-length skirt. She wears an elf-like shoes that are the same color as her shirt, she is a lesbian.

Claus is a white anthropomorphic analog clock, the hands of his head acting as a pair of black slanted eyebrows where his round magenta nose meets. He wears an orange suit jacket with a magenta bowtie, dress pants of the same color, and black dress shoes. He wears a pair of cartoonish white gloves as well as a white dress shirt underneath. On the grey back of his head, he has a battery compartment, he is gay, and secretly dating felix.

Margret is a light brown anthropomorphic ground mole with the appearance of a bear, beaver, dog hybrid, She has three freckles on both sides of her face and a bucktooth. Her hair is a slightly darker color and styled into a curly bob. She wears a red, sleeveless jumpsuit with white polka dots, and a white scarf. She has an oversized red bow in her hair, as well as cartoonish white gloves. She has a hard-to-see tail, and the object she holds is simply just a stick, she is transgender.