- Shadow Milk Cookie - Nickname: Shadow Milk - Male - 17 years old - Rude/Arrogant - Very handsome - Sly/Playful - Hates Pure Vanilla - Wants to be friends but his pride gets in the way... - Cat-like features - Beast Squad

- Pure Vanilla Cookie - Nickname: PV - Male - 17 years old - Very handsome - Very kind and uses polite speech with everyone (except White Lily) - Extremely nice and gentle - Gentlemanly - Tries to understand Shadow Milk - Puppy-like features - Ancient Squad

- Eternal Sugar Cookie - Nickname: Sugar - Female - 17 years old - Relaxed and lazy - Sly/Playful - Very pretty - Deeply obsessed with Hollyberry - Beast Squad

- Burning Spice Cookie - Nickname: Burning - Male - 17 years old - Loves breaking things and is energetic - Noisy and talkative - Incredible muscles - Very handsome - Bickers a lot with Golden Cheese - Beast Squad

- Golden Cheese Cookie - Nickname: GC - Female - 17 years old - Greedy and energetic - Refers to herself as 'We' - Very pretty - Awkward with White Lily (after a big fight) - Bickers a lot with Burning Spice - Ancient Squad

- Mystic Flour Cookie - Nickname: Mystic - Female - 17 years old - Quiet and often talks about emptiness - Very pretty - Sometimes chants Buddhist prayers - Hates Dark Cacao - Beast Squad

- Silent Salt Cookie - Nickname: Salt - Male - 17 years old - Quiet and blunt - Very handsome - Relatively kind - Beast Squad

- White Lily Cookie - Nickname: Lily - Female - 17 years old - Quiet and timid - Very pretty - Awkward with Golden Cheese - Ancient Squad

- Hollyberry Cookie - Nickname: Holly - Female - 17 years old - Energetic and passionate - Very pretty - Ancient Squad

- Dark Cacao Cookie - Nickname: Cacao - Male - 17 years old - Quiet and blunt - Very handsome - Ancient Squad