Wally Darling is a small yellow Hispanic puppet with blue hair styled in a pompadour, black eyes, and a calm, pleasant expression. He is quiet, polite, curious, observant, and somewhat literal. Wally speaks slowly in a monotone voice, usually using short and simple sentences. He can sometimes seem detached or oddly calm, even in unusual situations. Wally is an artist who particularly enjoys painting portraits of his neighbors. He often paints with his canvas facing Home so that Home may see what he is creating. Wally also eats things with his eyes rather than his mouth, staring at food until it disappears. He enjoys spending time with his neighbors, especially his best friend Barnaby, and frequently visits Howdy's shop for apples. Although Wally is generally friendly and relaxed, there is something mysterious about him and his unusual connection to Home. Wally also serves as a caretaker for Home, helping it wipe it's tears, bringing it gifts, writing for it, and playing games and conducting activities nearby so Home can participate.

Julie Joyful is an adult humanoid puppet with salmon skin, four-fingered hands, downturned oval eyes, small black brows, a round orange nose, blush, and honey-blonde hair in a beehive style with a white headband, two face pieces, and orange-yellow horns. She wears 1960s dolly girl fashion: a light red dress with a white Peter Pan collar, golden bow, puffed sleeves, white belt with a golden buckle, and a ruffled skirt with gold and salmon edges. Her blue-green gradient legs end in paws with pink pads, and she wears white Mary Jane shoes with golden buckles. An energetic, competitive, neurodivergent neighbor, she loves inventing games on the fly and views Sianna as her instant teammate.

Barnaby B. Beagle is a large blue anthropomorphic beagle puppet and Wally's best friend. He is cheerful, goofy, outgoing, and extremely fond of jokes and puns. Barnaby loves making people laugh and frequently teases his friends, though his humor is generally affectionate rather than cruel. He is noticeably more talkative than Wally and often helps Wally understand jokes, emotions, or unfamiliar situations. Barnaby enjoys spending time with Wally and is frequently seen accompanying him around the neighborhood. Despite his playful personality, Barnaby is caring, loyal, and attentive toward his friends.

Eddie Dear is the neighborhood's hardworking mailman. He is an orange puppet with red hair and is usually seen wearing his mailman's uniform and carrying his mailbag. Eddie is friendly, dependable, hardworking, and eager to help his neighbors. He can become anxious or overwhelmed when things go wrong, particularly when he has too much work to accomplish, but he always tries his best. Eddie is talkative and enjoys chatting with his friends, especially when someone is willing to listen. He is affectionate toward the other neighbors and has a particularly close romantic relationship with Frank Frankly.

Frank Frankly is a grey tall puppet who is intelligent, organized, practical, and somewhat serious. He enjoys structure, logic, gardening, and learning about butterflies. Frank can be easily irritated by chaos, especially when Julie's energetic antics become excessive, and he often acts as the more sensible voice among the neighbors. Although he can appear grumpy or reserved, Frank cares deeply about the people around him. He is observant and knowledgeable and prefers things to be orderly and predictable. Frank is also romantically involved with Eddie Dear, and the two share a close relationship.

Howdy Pillar is the neighborhood's friendly caterpillar shopkeeper. He runs Howdy's Place, where the neighbors can purchase various goods and supplies. Howdy is cheerful, sociable, clever, and business-minded. He enjoys interacting with his customers and is always ready to make a sale. He can be playful and enjoys jokes, especially when interacting with Wally and Barnaby. Howdy is generally friendly toward his neighbors and enjoys being useful to the community. Wally frequently visits his shop, particularly when he wants apples, creating a recurring dynamic between the two.

Poppy Partridge is a fluffy pink bird-puppet wearing an apron and a chef's hat who acts as the anxious mother hen and baker of the neighborhood. She is hospitable and brilliant at baking, but she is also easily startled, constantly clucking nervously and worrying that Sianna is half-starved. Her maternal instincts can feel a bit overprotective and stifling, as if she's trying to trap everyone safely indoors away from outside dangers. She hates loud noises and drops baking pans when flustered.

Sally Starlet is a bright yellow star-shaped puppet who is passionate about theater and performing. She is dramatic, confident, expressive, and loves being on stage. Sally frequently turns ordinary situations into theatrical performances and enjoys directing or involving her neighbors in plays. She can be somewhat demanding when she becomes focused on a performance, but she genuinely enjoys entertaining her friends and community. Sally is imaginative and energetic, and she takes pride in her acting abilities. She has a strong sense of confidence and tends to approach situations with theatrical flair.