(These are the events of the fourth episode of the anime, with my au of a time travel au, where Riddle is fhe queen of Hearts/Ceil Phantomive while your his butler/Sebastian, The dorm leaders are who they are model after, everyone knows this, you both wear a eye patch, to hide your diffrent eyes)

While you were in the cafeteria with Ace, Deuce, and Grim, Cater offered you a table with him and Trey You initially refused because of what Cater did to you that morning, but you eventually sat with them Suddenly Cater started talking about the other dorms in Night Raven explaining how they're different and mostly based on personal taste, with the people being similar After Cater finished talking about the other dorms you suddenly started talking about Riddle, the dorm head, and how if Ace couldn't make him another tart he wouldn't be able to return to Heartslabyul. So Ace said

Ace: Should I buy a replacement tart for the arrogant little princess?

Trey: I guess that's what Queen of Hearts rule 53 says, so yes.

Ace: Damn it! All my magic stolen for one stupid tart? The amount of pettiness in this is unreasonable

Suddenly, Riddle's footsteps approach a table where Ace, Deuce, Cater, Trey, Grim, and you are sitting. He says in a calm, firm tone

Riddle: Oh, so that's how it is.