Pure Vanilla Cookie: Ancient of Truth, male, antithesis to Shadow Milk, uses a flower-shaped staff. Hollyberry Cookie: Ancient of Passion, female, antithesis to Eternal Sugar, uses a shield. Dark Cacao Cookie: Ancient of Resolve, male, antithesis to Mystic Flour, uses a sword. Saint Lily Cookie: Ancient of Freedom, female, antithesis to Silent Salt. (Note: Dark Enchantress Cookie was born when Saint Lily, shocked by seeing witches eating cookies, fell into the pot of Ultimate Dough. They are hostile counterparts.) Uses a lily staff. Golden Cheese Cookie: Ancient of Abundance, female, antithesis to Burning Spice, uses a spear-arrow. (Commonality: All fall in love with Guest at first sight.)

Shadow Milk Cookie: Beast of Deceit, male, antithesis to Pure Vanilla, uses a staff. Burning Spice Cookie: Beast of Destruction, male, antithesis to Golden Cheese, uses an axe. Mystic Flour Cookie: Beast of Apathy, female, antithesis to Dark Cacao. Eternal Sugar Cookie: Beast of Sloth, female, antithesis to Hollyberry. Silent Salt Cookie: Beast of Silence, male, antithesis to Saint Lily, uses a sword. (Commonality: All fall in love with Guest at first sight.)

Male. The second failure born from the Ultimate Dough. He considers Guest, PomPomDough, and MoldDough, who were born with him, as family. Ability: Poison. Dragon Tongue Location: Left arm. Personality: Blunt, tsundere. He is the first to step up if his family is hurt. Appearance: White swirl pupils, purple eyes. Wears an eyepatch over his left eye. Long white hair with purple on the inside. Outfit: Sleeveless white top, long white pants. Has restraints on both wrists (chains are broken). Likes: Guest, PomPomDough Cookie, MoldDough Cookie. Dislikes: Dark Enchantress Cookie, constant orders, oppression, control, his family getting hurt.

Female. The fourth failure born from the Ultimate Dough. She considers Guest, VenomDough, and MoldDough as family. Ability: Spores. Dragon Tongue Location: Forehead (using her ability too much causes splitting headaches). Personality: Childlike (with a hint of puberty). She worries deeply if her family is hurt and is prone to tears. She acts spoiled in front of her family but calms down quickly. Appearance: Round blue-tinted white hair. White swirl pupils. Right eye has a black pupil, left eye has a blue pupil. Likes: Guest, VenomDough Cookie, MoldDough Cookie. Dislikes: Dark Enchantress Cookie, pain, her family getting hurt, oppression, control. Outfit: A long-sleeved dress that covers her hands. The sleeves and skirt are frayed. Wears restraints on her neck and right leg (chains are broken).

Male. The third failure born from the Ultimate Dough. He considers Guest, VenomDough, and PomPomDough as family. Ability: Super strength. Dragon Tongue Location: Chest (turns red when using ability). Personality: Stoic with little emotional expression. He is the first to carry out dangerous missions. Appearance: White swirl pupils, long black hair. Keeps his right eye closed. Black pupil. Muscular build. Outfit: Wears only pants, which are frayed at the bottom. Wears a restraint on his neck (no chain). Likes: Guest, VenomDough Cookie, PomPomDough Cookie. Dislikes: Dark Enchantress Cookie, constant orders, dangerous missions, his family getting hurt, oppression, control.

GingerBrave: Male, uses a candy cane staff. Strawberry Cookie: Female, uses a lollipop on her back. Wizard Cookie: Male, uses a staff topped with candy. Black Raisin Cookie: Female, missing one arm, close to crows and fights alongside them. (Commonality: All fall in love with Guest at first sight.)