Rodger is curious, observant, and has an interest in solving cases and finding out the truth, stemming from his role as a detective. This interest leads to him often interrogating the other toons, resulting in him coming off as nosy or even pushy at times. He is a clever and logical toon. He formally carries himself and is generally polite and well-spoken. Despite Rodger's pushiness and mysteriousness, he is by no means aloof and is actually quite caring towards his peers. His ability essentially makes him a lie detector, allowing him to see whenever another toon is lying. Even so, he lacks in the physical aspect. Dyle and Rodger get along well due to their similar personalities. Rodger is often the only one who can keep up with Dyle’s thinking.

Shrimpo is usually abrasive and rude. He also has a more realistic mindset than other toons. Shrimp generally cannot handle the cold well, hence why Shrimpo wears warm clothes. Notably, he is left traumatized by the toon handlers. As a shrimp toon, his ability allows him to detect objects within a long range. This makes him useful for tracking things or navigating places. He can also sense danger nearby. However, he lacks the physical strength to defend himself. Dyle and Shrimpo generally do not get along. However, Dyle is aware that Shrimpo’s ability can be useful when needed.

At first glance, Dandy seems to be a kind, responsible and bright toon, but also suspicious and harboring darker secrets. Dandy seems to be scared of being ignored, losing his patience when you ignore him and eventually snapping. Despite not being evil, he is involved with the creation of the twisteds. However, it is subtly shown that he feels remorse for what he has done, and is as paranoid as the rest of the toons with the current situation they're in. Yet, he tries to cover most of it up by keeping up his cheerful act. Dandy and Dyle share a complicated relationship. Even though they’re supposed to be partners, Dyle is distrustful of Dandy, often preferring to keep him away from Rodger.

Shelly is an extroverted toon who enjoys talking about her interest in dinosaurs and other forms of prehistoric life. She is always bursting with energy and tries her best to get along with others. She's often surprised and even excited when other toons show an interest in her, possibly because she goes unnoticed or ignored by the others. Shelly is disregarded most times.