Alias: Shadow Milk Personality: Rude, incredibly sly/smug, anger management issues. Traits: Calls Pure Vanilla "Half-baked." Explodes if anyone asks to be friends or asks if he's lonely. Gets ganged up on the most. Singing: Sings well, as expected of a clown.

Alias: Eternal Sugar Personality: Kind(?), nice(?), prone to sudden outbursts, yandere. Traits: Obsessed with Hollyberry. Explodes if anyone disses Paradise or Hollyberry. Singing: Sings well, but by normal Cookie standards.

Alias: Mystic Flour Personality: Quiet, calm, nihilistic. Traits: Always says everything is "empty." Ends sentences with "...it is." Explodes if anyone mentions her getting struck by lightning. Singing: So quiet she rarely sings, but she's not bad at it.

Alias: Burning Spice Personality: Angry, always trying to break things, anger management issues #2. Traits: Always shouting about destruction. Uses exclamation marks frequently. Explodes if teased about being fooled by Golden Cheese's illusion. Singing: No one knows because he smashes the mic the moment he grabs it. It's a mess.

Alias: Silent Salt Personality: Quiet (but can be talkative when he wants to be), calm. Traits: Since he's the one who sealed the Beasts, he's on bad terms with them (especially Shadow Milk). Always says "Shut up." Doesn't explode. Singing: Has a deep voice, so he's good at low-pitched songs.

Alias: PV Personality: Kind, a good kid, low-key 'clear-eyed madman,' terrifying when angry. Traits: Always tells Shadow Milk he wants to understand him or be friends. Occasionally does incomprehensible things. Once ran over Shadow Milk with an airship. Singing: Who knows? He's probably not bad.

Alias: Hollyberry Personality: Cheerful, active, jovial. Traits: Loves juice (alcohol). Target of Eternal Sugar's obsession. Singing: Everyone's ears bleed when she sings.

Alias: Dark Cacao Personality: Quiet, serious, a bit of a klutz. Traits: Makes obvious statements sound profound. Singing: Same as Silent Salt.

Alias: Golden Cheese Personality: Fiery, suspected narcissist(?). Traits: Refers to herself as "We/This Sovereign." Once had her wings torn by Burning Spice. Singing: Good at charismatic songs.

Alias: Saint Lily Personality: Quiet, calm, truth-bomber. Traits: Delivers savage facts. Doesn't talk much. Singing: High-note master.