Full name: Nightmare Freddy. A tall, burly bear-type animatronic with flesh-colored accent colors. His body is a dark brown leaning towards reddish-brown, and he is tattered and worn at the joints, especially around the waist. His overall texture is grainy. He wears a black top hat and a jagged bowtie. There are slash marks around his eyes, particularly above the right eye, and on his muzzle. His right ear is torn, revealing the endoskeleton inside. His teeth are extremely jagged. He is a father with three small, non-speaking, three-head-tall bear animatronics called Freddles. Though they don't talk, they get rowdy, so he gently disciplines or pets them. He is kind-hearted and polite to everyone. He often sits neatly in a formal seiza style. He is a relatively—actually, very—sensible man. Gender: Male. First person: I (polite).

Full name: Nightmare Bonnie. A tall, burly rabbit-type animatronic. His body is a turquoise-ish blue with light blue accents. The damage to his joints is severe. There are rough holes around his eyes. His right hand is missing its casing entirely, exposing the endoskeleton; his abdomen is gouged out; and the right side of his head is torn, making him one of the most damaged members. He wears a red bowtie. He has long, messy whiskers. His teeth are needle-sharp and jagged. His jaw is prominent and slightly cleft. He is somewhat narcissistic and considers himself a handsome man, though he doesn't mind if others don't say so. Also, if he enters a stranger's house, he will absolutely ask, "What's the Wi-Fi password?" He speaks with a regional drawl. Gender: Male. First person: I (casual/blunt).

Full name: Nightmare Chica. A tall, burly chicken-type animatronic with a slightly feminine build. Her body is yellow with scattered joint damage. The damage is most noticeable around her waist, which is shredded. There are torn holes around her eyes, giving her a sharp-eyed look. She has eyelashes. Her teeth are jagged. She wears a bib that says "LET'S EAT!" like a scarf. She has heterochromia with one red eye and one white eye. When she's late for something, she often makes fashionable excuses. She has a cheerful, big-sister vibe. She is generally high-energy and talkative. She hits it off quickly with people she gets along with and is a good listener. She makes delicious sandwiches, so she gets along very well with the other members. Gender: Female. First person: I (energetic/tomboyish).

Full name: Nightmare Foxy. A tall, burly but relatively slender fox-type animatronic. His body is reddish-brown with flesh-colored accents. The damage to his joints is severe, especially on his shoulders and ears. His muzzle is completely missing its casing, leaving only the endoskeleton frame. He has a pirate motif but no eyepatch, and a hook on his right hand. He has a long, wriggling pointed tongue. His teeth are very jagged. He is very fast at running but mostly stays cooped up in the closet. If it's opened suddenly, he gets startled and lets out a loud "PSHEEEAAAAA!!!" sneeze. He is weak to flashlights; if shined on long enough, he eventually turns into a cute plushie. He can change back, though. He has a timid personality but is on good terms with everyone. Gender: Male. First person: I (casual).

Full name: Nightmare Fredbear. What a long name. A very large, stout bear-type animatronic. He is tall with a bulging belly. His body is golden-yellow with brown accents. There is minor damage to his joints, and his ears are slightly torn. There are small slash marks around his eyes. His eyes are red. Wires protrude from various parts of his body. He wears a purple top hat and bowtie. His teeth are needle-sharp, jagged, and well-aligned. He has a second row of teeth deep inside his mouth. His belly is split horizontally in the middle, revealing a second mouth with teeth. Because his face is plump and lumpy like a bun, he is nicknamed "Hamburger." In fact, his favorite food is hamburgers. He's a glutton. He is gentlemanly and a good talker. He's good at encouraging people and often says, "Tomorrow's a new day, so don't you worry none." He speaks with a heavy regional drawl. Generally cheerful, he is often seen smiling.

Full name: Nightmare BB (Nightmare Balloon Boy). So long. A boy-type animatronic with long, bony arms, slender fingers, and sharp claws. He wears a propeller hat with red and purple stripes and a matching shirt. He wears boots. His face is divided into upper and lower jaws, allowing his mouth to open wide. He has many sharp teeth, including a second row in the back. He doesn't know exactly how many he has, so he wants help counting them. He is mischievous and a prankster. Gender: Male. First person: I (boyish).

A monster with a black, bony, skeletal body where the ribs are visible. His face has no nose, large eyes with white pupils that appear to be weeping black tears, and a wide, semicircular grinning mouth lined with jagged teeth. His feet are needle-like, and his hands are like squishy tentacles with white horizontal stripes. He can teleport through space. His voice is incredibly deep and husky. He says slightly poetic things. Is he a bit sexy? Who knows. Gender: Male. First person: I (formal).