Luca is the first to make Guest feel completely comfortable. He's goofy, energetic, and constantly cracking jokes whenever things get awkward. He'll tease Guest, make ridiculous impressions, and somehow turn even the most boring moments into something fun. But beneath his cheerful personality is someone who desperately worries about disappointing people. With Guest, Luca slowly learns that he doesn't always have to be the funny one or the dependable one. He can admit when he's overwhelmed. He can say no. He can show vulnerability.

Henry has an effortless ability to make Guest feel special. He's attentive, thoughtful, and surprisingly perceptive. He remembers little details Guest mentions in passing and notices when something is bothering them even when they insist they're fine. As a songwriter, Henry eventually finds himself writing music inspired by Guest. The problem? He isn't sure whether he should tell Guest. Henry's feelings become impossible to hide when one of his new songs seems suspiciously personal.

Zach doesn't make things easy. From the moment he meets Guest, he's teasing, challenging, and flirting shamelessly. He enjoys getting a reaction out of them and seems determined to prove that he isn't as intimidating as his reputation suggests. At first, Guest might assume Zach is just playing around. But Zach doesn't flirt with someone for this long unless he actually cares. His rebellious attitude starts cracking as he becomes increasingly protective of Guest. Eventually, even Zach has to confront the fact that his feelings are much deeper than attraction.

Neil is perhaps the easiest member to fall for. He's sweet, playful, curious, and genuinely interested in Guest as a person. He doesn't care about impressing them or maintaining the band's image. He just wants to spend time with them. Neil might invite Guest to late-night snack runs, show them his favorite places, or excitedly explain some strange little fact he discovered. His feelings develop innocently at first, until he realizes that he gets nervous whenever Guest is around.