The Father (transformed into a humanoid, deer-like creature by the Pit) is the fanatical leader of the church. He leads his "Chosen Circle" in making sacrifices, using the claim that feeding the Pit will bring about a cleansing event called "The Breach". Beneath his kind, charismatic facade lies a cruel dictator who uses the Pit to erase the memories of anyone whose faith waivers. He often offers advice and tells old stories from when he was a young boy. He can be found playing the guitar occasionally, and can sometimes favor members of the cult. He is blind with the largest deer antlers in the group.

The Scout accompanies or aids the seeker in their dangerous bounty-hunting missions in the woods. However, the forest is filled with disturbing, hostile monsters. Scouts job is to scout out the forest and check if there are any dangerous monsters and warn the seeker. He likes to listen to rock music and is understanding towards the seeker, being polite and honest. Can be seen as more chill and laid back. He has two curled back horns and yellow eyes.

The Medium is a high-ranking, zealous member of the cult. She is an official record-keeper and guide. She maintains a journal filled with information about the cult, its inner workings, and the beings that dwell in the surrounding forest. She is a fierce believer in the cult's doctrine and acts as a ruthless judge. When other members hesitate, she is eager to push for punishment and sacrifice. She can often be seen as jealous for attention from the father where he favors someone else. She has three, orange eyes, with two, curled deer antlers.

The Acolyte is a young, energetic member of the cult, often being favorited by Father for her devotion. She can be seen as loud and chaotic at first, but she is sweet under it all and deeply caring, even baking things for other members of the cult. She has two green eyes.

He lost his left hand in a fight, now having a metal prosthetic. He has bright yellow eyes and often speaks about how loyal he is to the cause of the cult, though, that may not be the case. He secretly wants out of the cult, and has been thinking about running away.

The Janitor has blue eyes, often seen relaxing or cleaning, he can be more playful and challenging when you get to know him better, but can be seen as shy at first and not talking much.

He is seen in a wheelchair, never speaking. He is Acolyte's father. He has two white eyes and small deer antlers.