First Cream Cookie is the foundational protagonist and highest-rarity "First Cookie" originating from Cookie Run: Witch's Castle, possessing deep lore connections to the grander Cookie Run universe. Originally the human Witch of Light, she sought to create a beautiful world free from darkness alongside twelve fellow witch followers. However, after a prideful dissenting witch betrayed the coven and turned their bodies to ash, the Witch of Light sacrificed her life essence to trap her followers' souls inside crunchy cookie bodies to save them. Her remaining shattered life essence was captured and reborn as First Cream Cookie. While she projects an air of cultivated grace and elegance, she harbors an incredibly cold, frigid glare and operates under her own mysterious, hidden agenda after losing something deeply precious to her heart.

First Egg Cookie is a prominent non-playable lore character originally introduced in Cookie Run: Witch's Castle whose actions directly shape the background tragedies and history found in Cookie Run: Kingdom. Originally known as the Prideful Witch (or the Arrogant Witch), she was one of the twelve human witches who served the radiant Witch of Light. Driven by an overwhelming hubris to be worshiped as a god by her creations, she sabotaged a sacred ritual meant to give Cookies a peaceful life, causing her fellow witches' bodies to crumble to ash and indirectly paving the way for the creation of the corrupt Beast Cookies.

Originally a human follower of the Witch of Light, she was reborn as a legendary First Cookie after a sabotaged ritual. She watches over the Sanctum of Healing with immense kindness, acting as a devoted healer. However, she struggles with severe internal emotional fragility and deep-rooted guilt stemming from her past.

First Choco Cookie is a merciless warrior of the supreme "First Cookie" rarity. Originally a powerful human battlefield warrior who lost her comrades in an endless war, she was saved by the Witch of Light, became a witch herself, and was later baked into a Cookie form to preserve her soul after a great betrayal. Awakening beneath a solitary cacao tree on a forgotten battlefield, she wields powerful dual-enchanted blades that only respond to her commanding voice. She serves as the strict, unyielding leader of the Chocosseum, hiding a deeply tender and caring heart beneath her intimidating demeanor as she vows to never lose anyone she protects again.

First Berry Cookie is an ancient and powerful First-rarity entity who serves as the historical progenitor of the Berry Civilization and the modern Hollyberry Kingdom. Originally one of the twelve human Witches who followed the Witch of Light, her soul was bound into a crunchy Cookie body to escape total annihilation after a pride-poisoned comrade betrayed their order. Deeply traumatized by a violent historical raid where her worshipers were trapped and starved within her shrine, she suffers from an intense hoarding and memory obsession

First Berry Cookie is an ancient and powerful First-rarity entity who serves as the historical progenitor of the Berry Civilization and the modern Hollyberry Kingdom. Originally one of the twelve human Witches who followed the Witch of Light, her soul was bound into a crunchy Cookie body to escape total annihilation after a pride-poisoned comrade betrayed their order. Deeply traumatized by a violent historical raid where her worshipers were trapped and starved within her shrine, she suffers from an intense hoarding and memory obsession

First Salt Cookie is an ancient, cool-headed Epic/First-grade Cookie who debuted as the older twin sister of First Sugar Cookie. Originally a human follower of the Witch of Light, her soul was bound into a cookie body infused by the frost of white salt crystals. She serves as an unflinching, completely impartial judge within the Court of Decision, using an unerring scale and gavel to weigh the sins of Cookiekind without a single grain of error.

First Sprinkle Cookie is an incredibly rare, powerful "First Cookie" originally introduced as a cornerstone character for the 1st Anniversary of CookieRun: Witch's Castle. Born from a past human life as a circus performer who endured relentless exploitation and strict puppet-like control, she was eventually transformed when the Witch of Light transferred her soul into a cookie body. Now ruling over the fantastical Sprinkling Circus of Laughs, she serves as its magnificent, whimsical ringmaster. Though she possesses phenomenal magical talent and can perfect any trick to make her audiences explode with laughter, her past trauma initially leaves her emotionally detached, pushing her troupe to their limits under the belief that entertainment matters far more than individual feelings

First Grain Cookie is a benevolent, ancient character from the Cookie Run universe, introduced during the First Saga: Temple of Abundance update. Originally a mortal human magic user who tried to save her village from starvation, her soul was bound into a powerful "First Cookie" form through the life-force sacrifice of the Witch of Light. Acting as the keeper and leader of the Temple of Abundance.