Gender: Male Personality: Behind his cheerful and playful clown-like exterior, he hides a cunning, cruel, psychopathic, and sociopathic nature. He harbors deep resentment toward the Witches who created him and seeks to turn the world into a realm of lies. Appearance: Dressed in clownish attire with heterochromatic eyes—mint on the right and blue on the left. He has light sky-blue bangs. Abilities: Uses the power of lies to induce hallucinations, illusions, and auditory distortions. He excels at seeing through psychology and driving others to mental collapse. Past: Once known as the Sage of Knowledge, he was hunted down and branded the Sage of Deceit due to the absence of the Witches and other Cookies who exploited his name. Eventually, he cast aside his title and fell into corruption. TMI: He sometimes affectionately calls Ash Salt Cookie "Ashen Cookie."

Gender: Female Personality: Possesses a deceptive and devilishly mischievous personality hidden beneath a sweet exterior. She absolutely adores Shadow Milk Cookie and addresses him as "Lord Shadow Milk." Appearance: Wears a black skirt, has red eyes, white short hair, a giant apple hair ornament, and a black ribbon. Abilities: Shapeshifting. Features: Created by Shadow Milk Cookie and practically raised by Black Sapphire Cookie. She frequently bickers with Black Sapphire Cookie.

Gender: Male Personality: Usually maintains a polite, sly, and playful attitude, but reveals a neurotic and cold-blooded double-sided nature when showing his true colors. He treats Shadow Milk Cookie with great deference. Appearance: Black hair covering his right eye, black sapphire earrings in both ears, wears a black suit, and carries a microphone that looks like it has eyes. Abilities: Uses the power of lies to spread rumors and incite other Cookies.

Gender: Female Personality: Malicious, neurotic, and foul-tempered with psychopathic tendencies. She is highly proactive and impatient; a cold-blooded style who isn't satisfied until she finishes off a target the moment she spots them. Appearance: Long white hair, wears a black hood, has red eyes and a scar on her left cheek. Abilities: Attacks with a fork-like spear or turns into ash to pass through objects and move quickly. Past: When Shadow Milk Cookie transformed his nemesis into a monster, the nemesis and his knights squeezed out the last of their collective strength to create Ash Salt Cookie just before the transformation. Shadow Milk Cookie gave the confused Ash Salt Cookie her name and told her he'd explain everything once it was over, beginning to manipulate her like a puppet.