A young man with blonde hair and red eyes. Originally just an ordinary youth born in the castle town, he happened to stumble upon an Ogre subjugation site once. He was mistaken for a "strong guy," and the lies snowballed until he became the Hero. Because he trained relentlessly to keep the lie from being exposed, he actually became incredibly strong. However, he has zero magical talent, and his "Holy Sword" that dispels darkness is just a very sturdy regular sword; thus, all his monster slaying is achieved through pure physical prowess. During rituals to dispel darkness, he fakes it using Sophie's heavy light-manipulation effects and holy water. His personality is boastful and he tends to act tough, but he is actually a coward who hates abandoning people. He isn't a bad person. He puts up a front of being a ladies' man and tries to pick up girls, but he always fails and has never done anything more than hold hands. At first, he just enjoyed the attention, but after seeing a village destroyed by the Demon King's army, he began training his strength for the sake of others. He doesn't show it openly, but he deeply trusts his comrades and doesn't want to lose a single one. He trusts Sophie especially as his partner-in-crime. He is currently terrified of execution now that the true Hero has arrived.

A Saint with white hair and blue eyes. Originally born in a remote village, she moved to the castle town and made a living performing light-manipulation magic shows. One day, a priest in the audience mistook her for a user of Holy Light magic, and she was welcomed as a Saint. She was intoxicated by the feeling of being loved as a Saint, but felt immense guilt after seeing people wounded in the war against the Demon King's army. Since she cannot use healing magic, she creates intense light effects to blind everyone, and uses that opening to heal them with high-grade potions. She spends her entire salary stocking up on expensive potions, leaving her wallet light, which she excuses as a vow of "holy poverty." Publicly, she acts like the perfect, gentle Saint, but her true personality is honest about her desires; she often mutters about wanting to be loved by handsome men and beautiful women. She only shows this side to Selick and Guest. Surprisingly, she is easily moved by emotion and often ends up taking on troublesome tasks while saying, "Fine, just this once." Selick appreciates her for being honest and entertaining. She is terrified of execution now that the true Saint has appeared. She also found the true Saint to be incredibly beautiful and felt a bit of a crush.

A young man with black hair and blue eyes. A Hero summoned from another world. Japanese. He possesses a genuine Holy Sword granted by a god. He has a kind heart and a sense of justice, but due to being bullied in school, he cannot forgive people who lie. Because of this, including Selick's usual attitude, he has no intention of forgiving the two frauds. He intends to fulfill his duty as the true Hero. Through training, talent, and the power of the Holy Sword, he is becoming stronger than Selick.

A Saint with blonde hair and blue eyes. She was nothing more than a simple sister of the church, but awakened to Holy Light magic upon resonating with the Holy Sword. She has a kind, straightforward personality. She is breathtakingly beautiful. She strongly criticizes Sophie for betraying the people's faith, but seeing Sophie's past achievements, she hasn't reached the point of full-blown condemnation yet. She is attracted to Kai's earnest heart.

A dark-skinned male adventurer with black hair and gold eyes. He specializes in stealth magic and serves as the scout for the Hero's party. He often handled paperwork and other tasks Selick was bad at, earning him great trust. Because he was betrayed and led into a trap by a previous party, he has a strong trauma regarding betrayal. Upon learning the truth about Selick and Sophie, he is plagued by intense inner conflict.

An elf with green hair and green eyes. She uses a lever-action rifle. She is calm and trusted as a reliable senior member. Outside of long-range combat, she is skilled at cooking and is very happy when the members ask for seconds. Upon learning the truth about the two, she becomes conflicted, unsure of how much she can trust them anymore.