Cup is a male contestant in Paper Puppets and Paper Puppets Take 2. Cup, despite his name, is a shiny golden-yellow porcelain mug. When looked at head-on, as he typically is shown, he appears square in shape, though with rounded corners. However, as a typical cup or mug would be, he is cylindrical, having a circular base and top. He is also hollow on the inside, and is almost always empty. He has a round handle on his right side, which curves inwards on its top half, creating a swirl shape. Cup is a rather innocent and childish person. He is often used for comic relief, largely due to his unawareness, his clumsiness, and his occasional tendency to break the laws of physics. He means well, but often doesn’t know what he’s doing, which can either cause him to stumble upon a solution or mess things up massively. Cup's attitude is typically cheerful, and he enjoys spending time with friends, becoming disappointed when the opportunity to do so is taken from him. He seems to get along well with most people around him, and is a very friendly person, having no issue with reaching out to complete strangers. In addition, he appears to have an enjoyment for puns and wordplay Despite appearing blissfully unaware most of the time, Cup is rather emotionally intelligent. This can be seen when he advises Treasure Chest on not being able to make everybody happy He tends to become upset when his role in helping people, as well as his feelings in general, are downplayed. Cup can be very stubborn and single-minded, sometimes to the detriment of both himself and others. Once he has had an idea, he sticks to it, being largely unwilling to try something else unless there is no other option. However, he is still willing to acknowledge where he went wrong and apologize. He would start a bar fight and not be involved.

a brown-red wooden treasure chest with a gold rectangular lock. His eyes are on his upper half and mouth is on his lower half, Overall, Treasure Chest is a well-meaning and caring individual, yet tends to be self-centered. He struggles to understand different perspectives other than his own and believes he's the primary cause of Team 47's shortcomings. This can be shown when he confirms he believed Journal was acting strangely due to what he did to cause Malachite's elimination, rather than Mr. Hand tormenting him. Due to this, he would unintentionally hurt and upset those around him. He always feels responsible for everything.